Aortic Valve Disease
There are two primary pathologies of the aortic valve; the valve can either be stenotic or insufficient (aka regurgitant). When the valve leaflets become stiff, it leads to a reduced orifice, and the pressure gradient across the valve increases, sometimes leading to decreased anterograde flow during systole; this can lead to several clinical consequences, usually beginning with left ventricular hypertrophy, which can later include dilation, decreased cardiac output, arrhythmias, ischemia, etc. Aortic insufficiency occurs due to inadequate closure of the aortic valve during diastole leading to retrograde blood flow from the aorta into the left ventricle. The consequences of this are an increase in left ventricular end-diastolic volume and wall stress.
Earn CME credit as you help guide your clinical decisions.
There are two common causes of aortic stenosis (AS), calcified (age-related) aortic stenosis and congenital bicuspid aortic valves. Rarely aortic stenosis and/or aortic regurgitation can be a result of rheumatic heart disease, although this is more commonly a disease of the mitral valve and generally seen in developing countries. Calcified aortic stenosis is by far the most common etiology and is believed to occur via progressive endothelial damage over many years.
Aortic regurgitation can occur in a chronic or acute setting. Causes of acute aortic regurgitation include type A aortic dissection extending to the valve or damage to leaflets from infectious or noninfectious endocarditis. The same pathologies most commonly cause chronic aortic regurgitation in developing countries as aortic stenosis, calcific disease, congenital bicuspid valve issues, and Marfan syndrome. Other less common etiologies include complications following percutaneous aortic balloon valvuloplasties and transcatheter aortic valve replacements (TAVR), as well as a slew of inflammatory disorders including but not limited to systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, and Takayasu arteritis. The most prevalent etiology of chronic aortic regurgitation in developing countries is rheumatic heart disease.
Aortic stenosis is a condition more prevalent in the elderly population (fifth through eighth decades). According to a prospective population-based study, the incidence of aortic stenosis was 0.2% during the fifth decade of life, 1.3% during the sixth, 3.9% during the seventh, and 9.8% during the eighth. When comparing the subset of patients with congenital anatomic malformations of the aortic valve to those patients with normal anatomy in those who underwent surgery for isolated aortic stenosis, the fraction of abnormal valves decreased with increasing age. In post-surgery patients less than 50 years of age, two-thirds were found to have a bicuspid valve. In contrast, one-third had unicuspid, ages 50 to 70 saw two-thirds of patients with bicuspid, but one-third had normal tricuspid anatomy. In patients greater than 70 years of age, 60% had tricuspid valve, and 40% had bicuspid.
Aortic regurgitation has an estimated prevalence of 4.9%, also increasing with age until the sixth decade when incidence begins to decrease. However, this number may be artificially low because up to 75% of aortic stenosis patients may have some degree of regurgitation that goes unreported.
Narrowing the valve in aortic stenosis occurs due to the fusion of the leaflets or calcifications that cause the valve to have decreased mobility and obstruct the orifice. Calcified aortic stenosis occurs via progressive endothelial damage that can initially cause inflammation and infiltration of macrophages and other inflammatory cells. This inflammation and damage lead to profibrotic factors that establish a collagen matrix, which not unlike bone formation, later becomes calcified. The most common consequences of aortic stenosis stem from decreased anterograde flow from the left ventricle into the aorta, leading to a backup of blood in the left ventricle and increased left ventricular pressures. This backflow can cause symptoms of heart failure beginning with left atrial dilation and mitral regurgitation and eventually leading to pulmonary edema and right-sided heart failure. A healthy aortic valve measures 3 to 4 cm; symptoms generally do not precipitate until the valve area has decreased to less than 1.0 cm. The more severely stenotic the valve becomes, the more difficult it becomes to maintain adequate cardiac output. The left ventricle undergoes hypertrophy and remodeling, which can lead to increased left ventricular oxygen demand; this coupled with decreased cardiac output can lead to ischemia and arrhythmias and decreased cerebral perfusion.
Aortic regurgitation leads to retrograde flow of blood from the aorta into the left ventricle, an increase in left ventricular volume, and dilation of the chamber. Initially, this leads to an increase in cardiac output and is maintainable for a prolonged period. However, this increase in cardiac output leads to distention and increased pressure in peripheral arteries, causing increased peripheral systolic pressure. Eventually, this causes worsening of the regurgitation, which can give rise to a rapid decrease in peripheral systolic pressure and, in severe disease, cardiovascular collapse (this phenomenon causes the characteristic wide pulse pressure in severe aortic regurgitation).
History and Physical
An in-depth history and thorough physical exam are essential, and commonly the first line of diagnosis for aortic valvulopathy. Symptoms of aortic stenosis or regurgitation often are not present or are too mild for the patient to notice until the pathology has become severe. Due to this, a careful cardiac physical exam is essential for early detection.
For aortic stenosis, a systolic ejection murmur can often be heard best over the right sternal border at the second intercostal space. This murmur will peak early during systole when the disease is mild, and as severity increases will peak later, it also tends to radiate to the carotid arteries along with a slowly rising carotid upstroke. Auscultation often reveals a sustained apical impulse as well. In severe disease states, a thrill can sometimes be palpated over the carotid arteries and aortic area. Additional physical exam findings due to complications and sequelae of aortic stenosis include those associated with heart failure and left ventricle remodeling, such as third and fourth heart sounds, pulmonary crackles, jugular venous distention, and pedal edema.
Aortic regurgitation when acute and/or severe can be suspected when the patient has a wide pulse pressure, and a low pitched early diastolic murmur is auscultated again over the right sternal border at the second intercostal space. Accentuated P2 may also be noticed due to elevated pressures in the pulmonary vasculature. Chronic aortic regurgitation may illicit a blowing diastolic decrescendo murmur with a positive correlation between the duration of murmur and the severity of the disease. Often auscultation of a laterally and inferiorly displaced apical impulse is present and sustained. Often there is the phenomenon of Corrigan pulse (water hammer), a bounding and forceful pulse that rapidly increases and collapses. Other less common physical exam findings include the de Musset sign, which is subtle head bobbing with a pulse, as well as the Quincke sign and Muller sign (pulsations on the fingernails and uvula, respectively). Similar physical exam findings to aortic stenosis can also be seen late in disease progression. Acute aortic regurgitation will present differently depending on the etiology. If a patient presents with tearing severe chest pain along with physical exam findings such as variation in blood pressure between the right and left extremities, consider aortic dissection as a cause. If the patient presented with a history of streptococcal infection along with fevers, swollen and tender joints, skin nodules, new onset of rash, then rheumatic heart disease would be high on the differential.
Chronic aortic regurgitation and late in disease progression of aortic stenosis symptoms generally fall into two categories; heart failure and decreased coronary and systemic perfusion. Overtime increased pressures in the left ventricle lead to congestive heart failure; patients may complain of pedal edema, shortness of breath, orthopnea, paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea, and exertional dyspnea. Patients may state that they require additional pillows at night to sleep because lying flat causes them to be short of breath. Additionally, patients may complain that they have decreased exercise tolerance, the number of city blocks they can walk before feeling short of breath or lightheaded decreasing. In severe disease states, patients may present with syncope or may also complain of anginal symptoms.
Diagnosis is first suspected based on either patient's subjective history or incidental finding on physical exam. Once there is suspicion of valvular disease, a 2D echocardiogram with Doppler study would be the gold standard test. There are three major parameters measured to evaluate the competency of the aortic valve during an echocardiogram; the aortic jet velocity, mean aortic valve pressure gradient, and the aortic valve area. These values are used in conjunction with the presence or absence of symptoms to determine the severity of the aortic disease. Other existing comorbidities and/or sequela can be investigated using imaging such as cardiac contrast tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging scan (MRI), stress testing, blood cultures for suspected endocarditis or rheumatic disease.
Treatment / Management
There is no medical management that can delay the progression of asymptomatic aortic valve disease. Management is a two-prong approach focusing on optimizing other cardiac comorbidities such as hypertension, coronary artery disease, left ventricular dysfunction, atrial fibrillation, and other arrhythmias and vigilante serial evaluation to monitor for disease progression and early detection of symptoms. Patients with Stage B mild aortic valve disease should have echocardiograms every 3 to 5 years, moderate every 1 to 2 years. For patients with stage C1 severe asymptomatic disease, echocardiography is necessary every 6 to 12 months. Regardless of stage, the development of new symptoms will always warrant immediate evaluation.
Valve replacement for aortic stenosis is recommended for asymptomatic patients (evidenced by history and/or stress testing) with a high-gradient disease or asymptomatic patients with severe AS (C2) and a left ventricular ejection fraction less than 50%. Indications for valve replacement for stenotic patients include any patients with severe stenosis (C or D) undergoing other cardiac surgery. New guidelines also show that aortic valve replacement is reasonable in a subset of patients:
- Asymptomatic (C1) with severe AS and decreased exercise tolerance or exercise fall in blood pressure
- Symptomatic patients with low flow/low gradient and reduced LVEF (D2) but a low dose dobutamine stress study showing aortic velocity greater than 4 m/s (or mean pressure gradient greater than 40mm Hg) and a valve area less than 1cm2
- Symptomatic patients with low flow/low gradient severe AS (D3) who are normotensive and have LVEF greater than 50%, if clinical, hemodynamic, and anatomic data support valve obstruction as the most likely cause of symptoms
- Moderate AS (B) patients undergoing other cardiac surgery; valve replacement may be a consideration for asymptomatic patients with severe AS (C1) and evidence of rapid disease progression with low surgical risk.
Valve replacement for the treatment of aortic regurgitation is indicated for symptomatic patients with severe AR regardless of LV systolic function (D), asymptomatic patients with chronic severe AR and evidence of LV systolic dysfunction (EF less than 50%; i.e., C2), and patients with severe AR (C or D) while undergoing cardiac surgery for any other indication. Valve replacement is reasonable for:
- Asymptomatic severe AR patients and normal LV systolic function (EF greater than 50%) but severe dilation of the left ventricle (left ventricular end-diastolic pressure greater than 50mm Hg; i.e., C2)
- Moderate AR patients (B) who are undergoing other cardiac surgery
- Asymptomatic patients with severe AR and normal LV systolic function (C1) but with evidence of progressive severe LV dilation (greater than 65 mm) if the surgical risk is low
Patients, whom life expectancy after the replacement is less than one year and/or quality of life is not expected to improve, would not be candidates for valve replacement. However, if life expectancy is greater than one year, and predictions include improvement in the quality of life, there are two methods for aortic valve replacement, surgical or transcatheter. Transcatheter aortic valve replacement is only indicated for aortic stenosis, not for aortic regurgitation. Electing one method over the other is determined by evaluating the morbidity and mortality risk of surgical valve replacement, often utilizing the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Predicted Risk of Mortality (STS-PROM). If the risk of serious complications or death is greater than 50%, transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is the preferred option. If the surgical risk is less than 50%, the consensus has been that SAVR is the preferred method. However, several studies are now showing that there is no difference in morbidity and mortality one year post-op between SAVR and TAVR and that TAVR is safe to use in any patient regardless of the risk level. There is one other procedure that sees occasional use for aortic stenosis patients, which is a balloon valvuloplasty. This procedure involves balloon inflation in the valve orifice in an attempt to widen the valve, used only as a temporary bridge to valve replacement for hemodynamically unstable patients or for palliative/symptomatic relief in patients who are not surgical candidates. The indications for valve replacement will be addressed in the staging portion of this review.
The differential diagnosis for patients presenting with aortic valve disease symptoms includes but is not limited to:
- Hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy
- Restrictive cardiomyopathy
- Constrictive cardiomyopathy
- Congestive heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF)
- Coronary artery disease
- Atrial fibrillation
- Atrial flutter
- Ischemic heart disease
- Pericardial effusion
- Pulmonary hypertension
- Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
- Restrictive lung diseases
- Symptomatic anemia
Pertinent Studies and Ongoing Trials
Transcatheter aortic valve implantation vs. surgical aortic valve replacement for the treatment of severe aortic stenosis: a meta-analysis of randomized trials showed reduced mortality with TAVR compared to SAVR, with data being most significant in transfemoral TAVR.
Chronic aortic disease is staged A to D. Stage A (at risk) is a patient with no change in hemodynamics of the valve and no symptoms but the presence of at least one risk factor, i.e., bicuspid valve, sclerotic valve, history of rheumatic fever, etc. Stage B (progressive) has mild hemodynamic changes with or without left ventricular dilation of early left ventricular diastolic dysfunction along with the presence of known risk factors, but the patient remains asymptomatic. Stage C1 (asymptomatic severe) includes severe hemodynamic changes on echocardiogram, presence of left ventricular diastolic dysfunction, without decrease left ventricular function, and no symptoms in daily life (however, symptoms may be precipitated with exercise stress testing). Stage C2 has the same hemodynamic parameters as C1 with a depressed left ventricular ejection fraction (under 50%). Stage D1 (symptomatic severe) is the high gradient (Vmax less than 4m/s) with left diastolic dysfunction, left ventricular hypertrophy, and potentially pulmonary hypertension accompanied by angina or heart failure symptoms on exertion. D2 (symptomatic severe) is low flow/gradient with reduced left ventricular ejection fraction (Vmax greater than 4m/s), decreased left ventricular ejection fraction (under 50%) and symptoms at rest. D3 (severely symptomatic) is the last stage and characteristically presents with a low gradient with normal left ventricular ejection fraction (aka paradoxical low flow), ejection fraction less than 50% is present, but stroke volume is less than 35mL/min; consequence small left ventricular chamber and restrictive diastolic filling. Stage D3 aortic stenosis also has symptoms at rest.
Prognosis is largely determined by the time of onset of symptoms. Asymptomatic patients who do not progress to symptomatic have a longer life expectancy. Prognosis of patients with severe symptomatic aortic valve disease who do not undergo valve replacement is very poor, with survival at 3 years ranging from approximately 40 to 60%, whereas those who underwent valve replacement ranged from 80 to 90%.
Deterrence and Patient Education
Patients need to understand the following points:
- Take all prescribed medications as directed.
- Consult with your clinician before taking any over-the-counter medications, vitamins, or herbal remedies.
- Be sure to keep all follow-up appointments, even if there are no symptoms.
- Maintain a healthy weight, but consult with your clinical team if exercise is permitted because some patients with aortic stenosis must exercise caution with exercise.
- If applicable, quit smoking.
Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes
The difficulty with diagnosing and treating aortic stenosis lies with the vast array of nonspecific symptoms the patient may present with, creating a substantial differential. In patients with whom cardiac comorbidities do not exist, and patients do not regularly see a cardiologist, the duty often falls on the primary care physician to perform a proper physical exam that includes auscultation of the heart as the first step in diagnosing asymptomatic aortic valve disease. If symptoms or physical exam findings warrant suspicion, it is vital to send the patient for an echocardiogram and consult a cardiologist for proper staging. A significant responsibility also falls on the patient to give a detailed history and description of symptoms and their progression. The sooner those symptoms are identified and management initiated, the better the patient’s long-term survival.
Proper management of comorbidities by primary care physicians, nurses, and other specialists is essential in ensuring the patient is optimized for surgery if necessary.
In summary, caring for patients with aortic valve disease requires an interprofessional team approach, including clinicians/specialists, mid-level practitioners (NPs and PAs), specialty-trained nurses, and pharmacists, all collaborating across disciplines to achieve optimal patient results. [Level 5]
(Click Image to Enlarge)
Akinseye OA,Pathak A,Ibebuogu UN, Aortic Valve Regurgitation: A Comprehensive Review. Current problems in cardiology. 2018 Aug [PubMed PMID: 29174586]
Vollenbroich R,Sakiri E,Roost E,Stortecky S,Rothenbühler M,Räber L,Englberger L,Wenaweser P,Carrel T,Windecker S,Pilgrim T, Clinical outcomes in high-risk patients with a severe aortic stenosis: a seven-year follow-up analysis. Swiss medical weekly. 2019 Feb 11; [PubMed PMID: 30957214]Level 2 (mid-level) evidence
Osnabrugge RL,Mylotte D,Head SJ,Van Mieghem NM,Nkomo VT,LeReun CM,Bogers AJ,Piazza N,Kappetein AP, Aortic stenosis in the elderly: disease prevalence and number of candidates for transcatheter aortic valve replacement: a meta-analysis and modeling study. Journal of the American College of Cardiology. 2013 Sep 10; [PubMed PMID: 23727214]Level 1 (high-level) evidence
Argulian E,Windecker S,Messerli FH, Misconceptions and Facts About Aortic Stenosis. The American journal of medicine. 2017 Apr; [PubMed PMID: 28109966]
Côté N,Pibarot P,Clavel MA, Aortic stenosis: what is the role of aging processes? Aging. 2019 Feb 11; [PubMed PMID: 30745466]
Yalta K,Palabiyik O,Gurdogan M,Gurlertop Y, Serum copeptin might improve risk stratification and management of aortic valve stenosis: a review of pathophysiological insights and practical implications. Therapeutic advances in cardiovascular disease. 2019 Jan-Dec; [PubMed PMID: 30803406]Level 3 (low-level) evidence
Turina J,Hess OM,Krayenbühl HP, [Spontaneous course of aortic valve disease and indications for aortic valve replacement]. Schweizerische medizinische Wochenschrift. 1988 Apr 9; [PubMed PMID: 3375789]
Ito S,Pislaru C,Miranda WR,Nkomo VT,Connolly HM,Pislaru SV,Pellikka PA,Lewis BR,Carabello BA,Oh JK, Left Ventricular Contractility and Wall Stress in Patients With Aortic Stenosis With Preserved or Reduced Ejection Fraction. JACC. Cardiovascular imaging. 2019 Mar 8; [PubMed PMID: 30878438]
Otto CM, Heartbeat: Improving diagnosis and management of aortic valve disease. Heart (British Cardiac Society). 2018 Nov; [PubMed PMID: 30366931]
Annabi MS,Clavel MA,Pibarot P, Dobutamine Stress Echocardiography in Low-Flow, Low-Gradient Aortic Stenosis: Flow Reserve Does Not Matter Anymore. Journal of the American Heart Association. 2019 Mar 19; [PubMed PMID: 30879376]
Kelly TA,Rothbart RM,Cooper CM,Kaiser DL,Smucker ML,Gibson RS, Comparison of outcome of asymptomatic to symptomatic patients older than 20 years of age with valvular aortic stenosis. The American journal of cardiology. 1988 Jan 1; [PubMed PMID: 3337000]
Aalaei-Andabili SH,Bavry AA, Left Ventricular Diastolic Dysfunction and Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement Outcomes: A Review. Cardiology and therapy. 2019 Mar 7; [PubMed PMID: 30847743]
Maes F,Lerakis S,Barbosa Ribeiro H,Gilard M,Cavalcante JL,Makkar R,Herrmann HC,Windecker S,Enriquez-Sarano M,Cheema AN,Nombela-Franco L,Amat-Santos I,Muñoz-García AJ,Garcia Del Blanco B,Zajarias A,Lisko JC,Hayek S,Babaliaros V,Le Ven F,Gleason TG,Chakravarty T,Szeto W,Clavel MA,de Agustin A,Serra V,Schindler JT,Dahou A,Salah-Annabi M,Pelletier-Beaumont E,Côté M,Puri R,Pibarot P,Rodés-Cabau J, Outcomes From Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement in Patients With Low-Flow, Low-Gradient Aortic Stenosis and Left Ventricular Ejection Fraction Less Than 30%: A Substudy From the TOPAS-TAVI Registry. JAMA cardiology. 2019 Jan 1; [PubMed PMID: 30566185]
Pineda AM,Kiefer TL, Asymptomatic Severe Aortic Valve Stenosis-When to Intervene: a Review of the Literature, Current Trials, and Guidelines. Current cardiology reports. 2018 Oct 11; [PubMed PMID: 30311005]
Tabata N,Sinning JM,Kaikita K,Tsujita K,Nickenig G,Werner N, Current status and future perspective of structural heart disease intervention. Journal of cardiology. 2019 Apr 4; [PubMed PMID: 30955999]Level 3 (low-level) evidence
Wong CHM,Chan JSK,Sanli D,Rahimli R,Harky A, Aortic valve repair or replacement in patients with aortic regurgitation: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of cardiac surgery. 2019 Jun [PubMed PMID: 30953445]Level 1 (high-level) evidence
Siontis GC,Praz F,Pilgrim T,Mavridis D,Verma S,Salanti G,Søndergaard L,Jüni P,Windecker S, Transcatheter aortic valve implantation vs. surgical aortic valve replacement for treatment of severe aortic stenosis: a meta-analysis of randomized trials. European heart journal. 2016 Dec 14; [PubMed PMID: 27389906]Level 1 (high-level) evidence
Forman R,Firth BG,Barnard MS, Prognostic significance of preoperative left ventricular ejection fraction and valve lesion in patients with aortic valve replacement. The American journal of cardiology. 1980 Jun; [PubMed PMID: 7377109]
Capoulade R,Pibarot P, Assessment of Aortic Valve Disease: Role of Imaging Modalities. Current treatment options in cardiovascular medicine. 2015 Nov; [PubMed PMID: 26391799]
Généreux P,Pibarot P,Redfors B,Mack MJ,Makkar RR,Jaber WA,Svensson LG,Kapadia S,Tuzcu EM,Thourani VH,Babaliaros V,Herrmann HC,Szeto WY,Cohen DJ,Lindman BR,McAndrew T,Alu MC,Douglas PS,Hahn RT,Kodali SK,Smith CR,Miller DC,Webb JG,Leon MB, Staging classification of aortic stenosis based on the extent of cardiac damage. European heart journal. 2017 Dec 1; [PubMed PMID: 29020232]