As the need for behavioral intervention and long-term psychiatric care is steadily rising, alternative methods of treatment must be employed by physicians and healthcare teams to meet this increasing demand. Group therapy provides a solution to this problem by allowing for the treatment of multiple individuals simultaneously. Doing so allows healthcare providers to reduce wait times and increase accessibility. This approach is especially necessary for rural and low-income areas where clinics are often understaffed and have a high volume of patients. Furthermore, group therapy can be used to treat a multitude of conditions including, but not limited to, emotional trauma, anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
Yalom Therapeutic Factors
It is vital to patient success that providers understand the mechanisms that exist in group therapy. These factors are:
Selection of Patients
When deciding which patients will benefit the most from group therapy, providers utilize the therapeutic alliance. The more the provider and patient agree on the goals and tasks of therapy as well as the stronger the relationship they share, the more likely the patient will have success in group therapy.
An additional selection method providers can use to gauge group therapy viability is the NEO-Five-Factor Inventory. This measure of personality suggests that those who score high on extraversion (openness) and conscientiousness (hard-working) dimensions are more suited for group therapy, while those who score high levels of neuroticism (emotionally reactive) are less suitable for group therapy.
Group therapy will be useful for the treatment of patients who exhibit interpersonal difficulties and pathology; patients who lack self-awareness; patients who are action-oriented; patients who suffer from isolation and require the stimulation group interaction provides, and those who will benefit from interacting with peers who can both challenge and support them.
Special attention must be paid to ensure patients unfit for group therapy do not get selected as their inclusion can have deleterious effects on both the patient and the group. Specific exclusion criteria are limited to patients who are unable to participate in the major activities of the group due to logistical, cognitive, or interpersonal factors. Additionally, patients in acute distress or actively suicidal should not be considered for group therapy and instead need independent management. Outside of these factors, the exclusion criteria for patients should be more relative than absolute. As a result, a patient unfit for one group due to conflicting personality traits may fit in a group that has similar traits to the patient.
Different Stages of Treatment
It is necessary to include patients at different stages of treatment to help facilitate individual recovery. By comparing themselves to other patients further along in the recovery process, patients can start to imagine themselves in a similar position. Additionally, seeing patients worse off than them but still contributing to the group can provide motivation, keeping patients committed to the treatment process.
Identical or Similar Conditions
Group therapy sessions should include members suffering from similar conditions. Doing so allows patients to realize that their symptoms are not exclusive to them, and others share similar feelings. This feeling of universality can create a sense of community within the group and facilitate the treatment process by fostering feelings of acceptance and belonging.
Structuring groups with members diagnosed with similar conditions also allow group members to learn from and instruct one another. Interpersonal learning allows members to gain new perspectives on their conditions and learn successful ways to cope. Additionally, members who typically experience social fear as a result of their symptoms become more comfortable with exposure to social situations.
In addition to adhering to the principles of group therapy, providers should use different styles of group therapy based on the diagnosis and needs of the patients.
Psychoeducational groups are useful for educating patients about their diagnosis as well as their inclinations and consequences associated with these inclinations. These groups also serve to encourage patients to stay committed to their treatment plans. Additionally, psychoeducational groups teach patients to avoid maladaptive behaviors while also instilling positive behavior change.
When organizing a psychoeducational group, the provider should follow a highly structured plan and develop a curriculum. Sessions should last anywhere from 15 to 90 minutes, and chairs should be organized in a horseshoe or circle configuration where the provider is the focus.
During psychoeducational group sessions, the provider will act as an educator. Teaching should be performed actively as passive note-taking is inefficient and allows patients to escape the focus of the group. To ensure patient engagement, providers must foster a culture of interaction by creating an environment where patients feel comfortable speaking. Additionally, when leading a session, the provider should incorporate different learning styles, such as visual learning, auditory presentations, and hands-on activities, to accommodate the wide variety of methods in which patients learn.
Skills Development Groups
Skills development groups are useful for patients whose diagnosis has prevented the adequate skill development necessary to function in everyday life. This style of group therapy also focuses on coping methods, emotional control, and socialization techniques. By focusing on specific skills that patients lack, providers can help prepare patients for the treatment process and give them the tools to recover.
Providers running skills development groups should base the content of the group on the needs of that group's patients. As a result, the actual material discussed will vary significantly from group to group. Skills development sessions should range from 45 to 90 minutes in length and be organized in either a horseshoe or circle configuration. These groups should be limited to 8 to 10 patients as it is highly interactive and provides ample time for each patient to practice the skills taught. The provider themselves must have mastery of the skills they plan to teach so they can effectively teach them to the group.
Cognitive-Behavioral groups are useful for changing patients’ learned behaviors by altering their beliefs and perceptions. These groups can also change patients’ perceptions of themselves, turning negative thoughts of being different and unlovable into more positive thoughts. This change in thought process can be extremely freeing to patients as they learn to live with their issues rather than being ruled by them.
The content discussed in these groups will also vary greatly. The provider should focus on beliefs, coping skills, thought process, or behavior based on the needs of the patients. The orientation of the room for this particular style of the group should be a circle as the horseshoe orientation can interfere with the cohesiveness of this group. Sessions should last anywhere from 60 to 90 minutes.
Similar to psychoeducational groups, the provider of cognitive-behavioral groups should take an active role during the session; however, discretion must be used to ensure the provider does not over participate negating the members' ability to interact. It is vital to the patients’ success that the provider acts as a guide and let the group work through most issues themselves.
Since the discussions in these sessions are focused on thought and behavior modification, patients may feel uncomfortable and try to resist these changes. Providers must be prepared for this resistance and gently guide the members through their issues with just the right amount of empathy and firmness.
Support groups can be used to help patients who have already begun receiving treatment to maintain their new behaviors and reinforce their new belief systems and thought processes. These groups also focus on the management of symptoms of day-to-day life. During sessions, patients usually discuss recent problems and how they dealt with them.
Support group sessions should last anywhere from 45 to 90 minutes. Sessions should also be conducted in a circular configuration.
Unlike psychoeducational and cognitive-behavioral groups, the provider of support groups is less directive and should act only as a facilitator. As such, the provider should assist patients in developing connections with one another and emphasizing similarities between patients. The provider’s main contribution to the group should be limited to positive reinforcement and to bring to attention appropriate interactions patients exhibit.
Providers should be aware of the different stages of group development as a transition through each stage indicates group growth and change. Transitioning through all five stages is necessary for patients to benefit from group therapy.
Length of Treatment
The duration of group therapy treatment is highly individualized and subject to a high degree of variation. Patients should receive therapy until they achieve relief from their symptoms and can begin to develop a normal life with strong relationships and a sense of belonging; this can take anywhere from weeks to months or even years to occur. To facilitate patient improvement, providers should structure the ending of therapy processes. By establishing a set end date during treatment, the provider can prepare the patient for an eventual departure with the patient working towards the achievement of his or her goals until that date.
Similar to individual treatment, the provider or group leader in group therapy sessions are bound to the laws of confidentiality concerning patients' medical history, diagnoses, and other personal information. The other group members, however, are not bound to these same laws and face no legal consequences for sharing information from sessions. As a result, individual patient confidentiality can be difficult to maintain, especially in larger groups where leaders have less control over what information gets shared within the group.
The ability to share personal information can play a positive role in the treatment process. Some patients may feel uneasy sharing certain details for fear of who may repeat them, which can cause harm to patients' mental wellbeing as they struggle to contribute while maintaining their confidentiality. To reduce this tension, providers should adopt a set of confidentiality/sharing guidelines that the group agrees to and discuss with members the limitations of confidentiality before the first session.
Research has shown that group therapy is an effective method to treat a myriad of psychiatric and behavioral disorders. Patients often report a reduction in symptoms after receiving group therapy treatment. Additionally, group therapy is found to affect patients positively through Yalom Therapeutic Factors. These factors do reduce symptoms of diagnoses while also providing patients with beneficial skills to learn, develop, and live with their symptoms. As long as patients are subject to proper screening before group therapy sessions, they will receive benefits.
Although group therapy is an effective method of treatment in itself, providers may also choose to incorporate other treatment methods to treat patients further.
Group therapy provides a cost-efficient method of treatment, as fewer trained professionals are required to provide treatment to a larger number of patients. A reduction in cost can increase the accessibility of therapy, as costs are often covered by insurance plans.
Treatment in a group setting allows providers to be more flexible with their sessions. Doing so can increase attendance to therapy sessions since providers can schedule sessions during after work and after school hours. Additionally, the inclusion of multiple sessions throughout the day allows providers to treat a larger volume of patients throughout the day, further reducing wait times in high volume areas.
The group format can be used as an avenue to train medical students, residents, and other healthcare professionals by allowing them to serve as co-therapists. The provider can oversee the less experienced professionals as they work with patients, effectively creating on the job coaching; this can be especially useful in low resource areas where access to trained professionals is limited.
Conflict is a natural and expected aspect of group therapy sessions. Many conflicts may not be obvious to the group members, and it is the responsibility of the provider to bring these covert conflicts to the members’ attention. The provider is not required to solve the conflict; however, he or she must make an informed decision on how to deal with the conflict based on the interest of the group. It may be worthwhile to address the conflict, as there is an opportunity for the group to learn.
Members’ responses to conflict can be complex and unpredictable. When conflict arises, providers should use the last five to ten minutes of the session to speak with patients individually and allow them to voice their concerns.
Patients Who Ramble
Occasionally, a patient may continue to talk for an unnecessary length of time. It is essential to address this patient and see what he or she hopes to gain when doing so. If the patient is unsure as to why they are dominating the conversation, the provider should use this opportunity to teach the patient how to express his or her thoughts and feelings better.
Lack of Engagement
It is the provider’s responsibility to ensure members are alert and attentive during group sessions. When members seem disengaged, the provider should interject and see why members are losing interest. The inclusion of interactive activities can help members to be more engaged in the group discussion.
Providers are encouraged to push their patients to engage with the sessions; however, it is crucial to be aware of a patient’s individual limits. If the provider’s initial request for the patient to continue engaging meets with resistance, then the provider should respect this wish. Providers should remain patient, understanding, and empathetic with their patients and continually encourage without forcing patients to act against their will.
Pharmacotherapy and Group Therapy
Occasionally, patients receiving group therapy will also benefit from the inclusion of pharmacotherapy. In situations where the provider prescribing the medication differs from the provider providing treatment, proper communication between the two parties is vital to patient success. A thorough report of the patient and his or her reaction and benefits from the medication must be shared with the provider treating with group therapy. Mutual respect for one another and the well-being of the patient are required to prevent adverse reactions and ensure the patient receives the highest quality of medical care. Additionally, putting less of a value on either of the two treatment processes can negatively impact patients, so the therapist should always follow proper inclusion and management of both treatment processes.
When pharmacotherapy is part of the patient's therapy, it is prudent to have a qualified pharmacist examine the patient's medication record, checking for proper dosing, potential drug interactions, and inform the other members of the healthcare team of any red flags.
Social workers can play an important auxiliary role to providers during group therapy sessions. The social worker's presence as a lay-person voicing their thoughts and feelings can help facilitate group interaction and reduce members’ resistance to contributing. Also, social workers can assist patients in attempting to reintegrate into their “normal” lives by answering patient’s questions concerning work, relationships, and other lifestyle changes.
An interprofessional team approach can benefit participants in group therapy, where information is shared among various disciplines leading to improved patient outcomes, so long as appropriate privacy considerations are maintained at all times. [Level 5]
Nurses trained in psychiatric and behavioral sciences can take on the role of group therapy leader and host group therapy sessions. Their responsibilities reflect those of other healthcare providers, and supervision is not required when a properly trained nurse is leading group therapy.
|||Deblinger E,Pollio E,Dorsey S, Applying Trauma-Focused Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy in Group Format. Child maltreatment. 2016 Feb; [PubMed PMID: 26701151]|
|||Wolgensinger L, Cognitive behavioral group therapy for anxiety: recent developments. Dialogues in clinical neuroscience. 2015 Sep; [PubMed PMID: 26487815]|
|||Sayın A,Candansayar S,Welkin L, Group psychotherapy in women with a history of sexual abuse: what did they find helpful? Journal of clinical nursing. 2013 Dec; [PubMed PMID: 24118587]|
|||Vidal R,Castells J,Richarte V,Palomar G,García M,Nicolau R,Lazaro L,Casas M,Ramos-Quiroga JA, Group therapy for adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 2015 Apr; [PubMed PMID: 25791144]|
|||Ezhumalai S,Muralidhar D,Dhanasekarapandian R,Nikketha BS, Group interventions. Indian journal of psychiatry. 2018 Feb [PubMed PMID: 29540924]|
|||Martin DJ,Garske JP,Davis MK, Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: a meta-analytic review. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology. 2000 Jun [PubMed PMID: 10883561]|
|||Lahey BB, Public health significance of neuroticism. The American psychologist. 2009 May-Jun [PubMed PMID: 19449983]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 319691]|
|||Malcolm L,Mein G,Jones A,Talbot-Rice H,Maddocks M,Bristowe K, Strength in numbers: patient experiences of group exercise within hospice palliative care. BMC palliative care. 2016 Dec 13; [PubMed PMID: 27964735]|
|||Ramírez P,Febrero B,Martínez-Alarcón L,Abete C,Galera M,Cascales P,López-Navas AI,González MR,Ríos A,Pons JA,Parrilla P, Benefits of Group Psychotherapy in Cirrhotic Patients on the Liver Transplant Waiting List. Transplantation proceedings. 2015 Oct; [PubMed PMID: 26518934]|
|||Larsson E,Lloyd S,Westwood H,Tchanturia K, Patients' perspective of a group intervention for perfectionism in anorexia nervosa: A qualitative study. Journal of health psychology. 2018 Oct; [PubMed PMID: 27473160]|
|||Hauksson P,Ingibergsdóttir S,Gunnarsdóttir T,Jónsdóttir IH, Effectiveness of cognitive behaviour therapy for treatment-resistant depression with psychiatric comorbidity: comparison of individual versus group CBT in an interdisciplinary rehabilitation setting. Nordic journal of psychiatry. 2017 Aug; [PubMed PMID: 28598705]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 8699541]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 8246317]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 8699538]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 3578607]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 25364143]|
|||Lasky GB,Riva MT, Confidentiality and privileged communication in group psychotherapy. International journal of group psychotherapy. 2006 Oct; [PubMed PMID: 17040183]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 24217864]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 7446786]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 24497254]|
|||CHANCE E, Group psycho-therapy and the psychiatric social worker. Mental health (London). 1948 Aug; [PubMed PMID: 18885358]|
|||[PubMed PMID: 23581992]|